Skip to content

The Combat Over The Legacy Of Dungeons & Dragons 

Gail Gygax and I had been sitting in the lounge of a lace-trimmed, flower-filled mattress and breakfast in Lake Geneva, Wisconsin when she instructed me concerning the time she found what she believed was a plot to kill her.It was a fall day in 2013, and it had been 5 years since her husband Gary, the co-creator of Dungeons & Dragons, had died. Since then, Gail had gotten assist round the home from a neighbor, Brian Terry. A stocky, 62-year-old bartender, Terry got here round to do issues that wanted doing, like mowing the garden or serving to her pack and ship the antiques she finds round Lake Geneva and sells on-line. That day, Terry was crossing Gail’s picket-fenced garden when his ft caught a barely-visible string of fishing line, set a foot above the bottom, wrapped a number of occasions round two sticks caught deep within the dust. Each of them agreed it was a lure. “My dwelling has been invaded,” Gail Gygax wrote final yr in a widely-circulated Fb publish. “There was a visit wire by my again step to kill me and I do know what’s lacking from our dwelling.” Gail Gygax in December, 2018.Picture: Cecilia D’Anastasio (Kotaku)In December of final yr, Gail Gygax contacted Kotaku by way of her agent. She wished to inform us about all the many risks—each bodily and psychological—she says she’s been coping with for the reason that demise of her husband Gary Gygax, who’s extensively thought of to be the daddy of the tabletop role-playing recreation, in 2008. Break-ins. Loss of life threats. Estranged kids. Visitations from her late husband’s spirit. Predatory businesspeople. And lawsuits—5 of them in whole, with one introduced by Hollywood producer Tom DeSanto for $30 million. Eleven years after the demise of Gary Gygax, there are nonetheless battles over who will management his legacy—the rights to his identify, his biography, his memorial, his mental property, and the way forward for numerous different priceless artifacts, amongst them Gary Gygax’s authentic dungeon, the maps to an 11-level magical fortress the place he prototyped a fantasy role-playing recreation that Eight million folks play yearly.“Did my life change? Yeah, it modified an entire lot,” Gail mentioned. At 63 years previous, Gail’s phrases had an edge to them, the sound of somebody poised to defend herself out of behavior. She wore a black silk Free Folks kimono embroidered with pink flowers. Her dangling black chandelier earrings waved as she shook her head. “Did I count on folks to be calling me dangerous names and treating me with disrespect? No, it completely blindsided me. As a result of I feel I’m doing the very best factor for my husband’s reminiscence. And I nonetheless am.” As strain mounts from all sides, Gail has sacrificed a lot of herself in defending that reminiscence. And as her declare to its real-world expressions is questioned by more and more highly effective events, she continues ahead like a shark that has to maintain swimming to keep away from drowning.Wisconsin within the winter is greige, like the colour an actual property agent may ask you to color your own home so a brand new household can think about their very own life there. In summertime, rich Chicagoans boat throughout the lake and graze the city’s many vintage shops, however at present, within the chilly, the roads of Lake Geneva had been empty aside from households in puffy jackets and patterned leggings crossing the road, both facet of which had a sweet retailer. A person at a sports activities bar drinks a PBR alone at 11:30 a.m. Gail, who instructed me she prefers to not carry new acquaintances to her dwelling, drove me down the road in her cluttered, dusty Volvo, heading for the mattress and breakfast.At 2:30 p.m., Gail pours herself a glass of wine. “I took care of him till the day he died,” she says.The demise of Ernest Gary Gygax at 69 from an inoperable aortic aneurysm on March 4, 2008, was one of many first issues Gail wished to speak about after we first spoke on the telephone, weeks previous to this assembly. “He wished to die at dwelling,” she mentioned. “Are you aware how arduous it’s to look at somebody die in entrance of you and care for them?” By the top, Gail mentioned, Gary didn’t need her going outdoors. The couple didn’t have the funds for for a nurse.On the morning of March 4, Gail mentioned she and Alex had been sleeping on the sofa. At 6 a.m., the time when Gary at all times roused himself from sleep, Gail mentioned that each she and her son had been dreaming the identical dream: that Gary was within the room telling them to get up. He had handed away simply hours earlier. Gail says she didn’t name any of Gary’s different kids to inform them the information. She mentioned she didn’t have their telephone numbers. (None of Gary Gygax’s 5 kids from his earlier marriage—Elise, Ernest, Luke, Cindy, and Heidi—nor Gary and Gail’s son Alex wished to talk with Kotaku for this story.)“The day Gary died is when it began,” she mentioned.Throughout the globe, Gary Gygax was eulogized in every single place from the New York Occasions to the Guardian, and in essays by pop fantasy titans like Wil Wheaton and Neil Gaiman. In his obituaries, Gygax was celebrated because the world’s first and best dungeon grasp, the daddy of role-playing and founding father of a convention that might feed the rise of blockbuster role-playing online game sequence like Remaining Fantasy, World of Warcraft and Skyrim. Gamers of the massively multiplayer RPG Eve On-line held a Viking-style funeral for Gygax, naming a ship after him and exploding it in area.That was the skin world, although. Within the nonetheless snowglobe of Lake Geneva, a small gathering of Gary’s closest buddies, household, role-playing collaborators, and enterprise companions collected in a somber beige room. The funeral was a small coming-together of the role-playing luminaries that Gary Gygax had created and picked up through the years. Admirer after admirer approached the rostrum with teary-eyed tales of Gary’s generosity and buffoonery. The tabletop role-playing web site despatched a banner with a whole bunch of followers’ names together with a bevy of floral preparations. Gary’s son Luke, an officer within the California Military Nationwide Guard, eulogized his father in uniform. On the finish of his speech, he saluted a portray of Gary, gray-bearded and smiling benevolently in a checkered sweater. On the wake, held on the American Legion Corridor, buddies, household and followers ran spherical upon spherical of tabletop video games all day in Gary’s reminiscence. Gail was not feeling celebratory. A nervousness had been insinuating itself. Gary’s kids, she feared, would blame her for not caring for him properly sufficient. They’d blame her for not speaking properly sufficient. Fantasies of future confrontations overwhelmed her. She feared a battle would get away at her husband’s funeral. To insulate herself, Gail mentioned, she employed an undercover, off-duty cop to accompany her to the funeral. Because the ceremonies concluded, Gail mentioned, she couldn’t discover the e-book the place visitors wrote messages to Gary. “They stole his funeral e-book,” mentioned Gail, not saying who “they” had been. “Then it simply stored going.” Gail mentioned she has now been battling the ambiguous “they” for 11 years in an effort to guard Gary’s legacy from the folks she believes try to steal it. A few of these the threats she’s combating appear to be specters. Others, like Tom DeSanto’s $30 million lawsuit, are very actual.Gail and Gary Gygax.Picture: Courtesy of Gail GygaxGrowing up Southern Baptist in Mayfield, Kentucky, Gail Gygax, née Carpenter, realized to by no means take something sitting down.“My mother raised us by herself. My dad didn’t assist us. Cash was tight. Residing was very tight, let’s simply put it that means,” she mentioned. “We realized that it’s a must to care for your self.”Graduating from a big Kentucky college with a level in accounting, Gail’s first job was within the workplace of an auto restore store close by the college. It wasn’t her preliminary aim. After school, she mentioned, she wished “to have sufficient [business] background so I’ll know sufficient and discover somebody I need to be in enterprise with.” Gail laughed as she recalled the restore store’s sketchy M.O. The mechanics, she mentioned, would usher in automobiles from all around the nation, roll their speedometers again, and ship them out once more. A suggestion to change into the media director of an promoting agency introduced Gail and her then-husband to Illinois, however when the wedding petered out, she moved into an residence together with her sister in close by Lake Geneva. Considered one of her new buddies there talked about that she was working for a humorous new firm referred to as TSR, or Tactical Research Guidelines, that made one thing referred to as Dungeons & Dragons. All Gail knew about TSR on the time was that “everyone on the town thought everyone on the market was bizarre.” At 28 years previous, Gail, who wore her hair brief and had a penchant for ‘80s-style enterprise apparel, had discovered herself working for an additional automotive dealership, and she or he fiercely wished a extra fast-paced, going-somewhere job. She was fortunate sufficient to use for one of many few jobs for which TSR didn’t have already got an inner candidate. As an administrative assistant to TSR’s chief monetary officer, Gail would learn each licensing contract that handed by way of the constructing and take conferences for her boss. All that point, she heard about TSR’s cofounder, the person himself, Gary Gygax. “Everyone loves Gary,” she remembers her boss saying. “Simply wait till you meet him.” Gail didn’t meet Gary for some time, however she remembers when she first caught a glimpse of him. It was the early ‘80s and Gary had simply arrived again from a summer season enterprise journey in Los Angeles. Gail caught a glimpse of him strutting by way of the workplace in a black mink hat and garments he’d picked up on Rodeo Drive. He had “an amazing presence,” she mentioned, “like some god strolling on water.”Gary Gygax’s hair was lengthy. His beard was full. He wore picket beads round his neck and was keen on Conan the Barbarian, a pulpy fantasy sequence seasoned with buxom damsels in misery and hardened warriors who would rescue them from peril. In 1970, he misplaced his job at a life insurance coverage firm, so Gary spent lengthy hours in his basement, cobbling footwear for more money, and pushing miniature warmen round grids in battle video games like Avalon Hill’s Gettysburg or Combat within the Skies at dwelling in Lake Geneva, the place he lived together with his redheaded townie spouse Mary Jo and their 5 kids. Gary created a fantasy wargame referred to as Chainmail in 1971, which a few of his biographers have mentioned fashioned the muse for Dungeons & Dragons. On the similar time, Gary was a prolific contributor to wargaming periodicals and play-by-mail video games, which endeared him to a Minnesota man named Dave Arneson.It was the ‘70s, and J.R.R. Tolkien’s Lord of the Rings books had boomed in gross sales, incubated partially by the last decade’s heavy psychedelia. Excessive tradition fertilized the soil for prime fantasy, and gamers of wargames that had been primarily based on real-world army battles had been beginning to consider making use of these rule units to unreal worlds.Arneson, a Minnesota safety guard, was a part of a tight-knit wargaming group that, like a modern-day tech incubator, innovated new wargames and kinds of play in neighborhood basements and round kitchen tables. Arneson’s Blackmoor, a Lord of the Rings-style dungeon exploration recreation, was birthed from these inventive embers. Arneson went to Gygax’s home in 1972 to fulfill his fellow wargaming head and run a recreation of Blackmoor for him. Following that go to, he mailed 18 pages of notes, the tough ruleset for the sport, to Lake Geneva. Impressed, Gary typed out one thing now known as The Fantasy Recreation. Gary’s son Ernie and daughter Elise scrawled out attributes and skill factors on notice playing cards. These stats guided them by way of battles towards a scorpion nest, some kobolds, and an enormous centipede, all as a part of the bigger fantasy marketing campaign. When phrase of The Fantasy Recreation acquired out, locals started becoming a member of the adventuring occasion. It was set in Gary’s authentic dungeon, Citadel Greyhawk, dominated over by Zagyg, Gary’s alter ego. Whereas parts of Gary’s dwelling marketing campaign, set in Greyhawk, have been revealed for many years, nonetheless, no model of “Citadel Greyhawk” devoted to Gary’s authentic design was revealed till near Gary’s demise. Its revealed identify was Citadel Zagyg. The unique dwelling marketing campaign is in Gail’s possession.“Zagyg does have parts that date to the very earliest phases of role-playing,” mentioned Frank Mentzer, a recreation designer who labored at TSR. Arneson, he mentioned, was the one who contributed cooperative role-playing as a recreation mechanic. “For the primary time in human historical past, we’ve the embracing of the idea that man can entertain himself with out having to defeat one other,” Mentzer mentioned. “You may cooperate, and benefit from the fruits of your cooperative efforts, with out having a loser. This can be a quantum leap within the soul.”Gail Gygax not lives within the dwelling wherein Gary created his video games. The house is at present owned by a girl who gamely permits Gygax acolytes entry yearly or so, for previous occasions’ sake. It was Paul Stormberg, a role-playing recreation archivist, who introduced me to what he referred to as “the Heart Avenue dwelling,” exhibiting me across the quaint, white outdoors as if we had been on a tour of the cave the place man invented fireplace. Stormberg lifted up a rusted boat that was protecting the door that led from the yard down into the cellar. “On the backside of this can be a door that claims ‘Entrance: Battle Video games room,’” he whispered. “That is the place D&D was created.”Stormberg, a former archaeologist with round glasses, clean-cut blonde hair, and an excitable disposition, sees the 1973 beginning of Dungeons & Dragons as nothing lower than a significant second in human historical past. “For 2 millennia, no new video games had ever been created,” he mentioned. “Human beings had solely created six forms of tabletop video games. Cube video games, plot video games, card video games, board video games, miniature video games and pen and paper video games like Cling Man.”“A seventh recreation was created by humanity. A seventh recreation! That didn’t exist earlier than! And it was created by two guys who lived in america in my lifetime! It’s only a recreation, proper, however millennia have passed by with out a new sort of tabletop recreation being created. That is the occasion horizon. We’re proper right here on the occasion horizon. We are able to’t see it. We’re not far sufficient away from it to grasp the way it has modified the world.” Gygax and Arneson knew they’d one thing probably earth-shattering with their recreation, however the conventional wargaming publishers like Avalon Hill weren’t biting. So Gygax and a few buddies fashioned their very own writer, TSR, in 1973, and launched Dungeons & Dragons, credited on the field to “Gygax and Arneson,” the following yr. After a brief interval of uncertainty, TSR grew quickly, doubling its employees round 1976. Gary was the editor, president, and CEO. D&D was promoting, however nonetheless, compensation was a difficulty. Early staff acquired cost within the type of inventory choices, royalty agreements and, generally, on a whim, a standard paycheck. By 1979, D&D was grossing about $2 million yearly for TSR, which was run out of a gaudy former lodge in downtown Lake Geneva.One Saturday night, Gail’s good friend, a former Playboy bunny, invited her to a cocktail party at Stone Manor, a historic lakefront mansion that had lately been transformed into condos. Gail drove over in her sister’s blue Volkswagen bug. As she parked, she caught sight of Gary Gygax taking out the rubbish. They’d by no means formally met. Gail stood outdoors, looking for an entrance into the constructing, when Gary requested if she was going to the occasion. That evening, Gary, who was separated from his spouse and within the technique of a divorce, requested her out, however solely months later did they lastly go to dinner, a barbeque—alongside Gary’s daughter Elise and his grandson, for his second birthday. In Gail’s recollection, she was was not well-received by Gary’s household.“I feel Gary was lonely,” Gail mentioned. “He was going by way of a divorce. He had lots of strain on him between firm funds, creating the gaming merchandise, and going to conferences in Los Angeles.” Gail began accompanying Gary on his biweekly journeys to Los Angeles, splurging on lunch on the Beverly Hills Lodge, procuring on Rodeo Drive, zipping round in a blue Cadillac Seville convertible chauffeured by Gary’s bodyguard.“Gary was cool,” mentioned Gail. “He was very refined. He would get right into a room and speak to anyone about something. He wasn’t introverted like lots of players. He wasn’t that means.” At dwelling, they shared the cooking and cleansing duties. Gail mowed the garden whereas Gary did the dishes. Gail grilled whereas Gary made soups. He’d throw each scrap of leftovers into an enormous casserole. Within the mornings, Gary would smoke unfiltered Camels on the porch. Within the evenings, he would learn the Bible. In the summertime, the porch was consistently alive with open-door events whereas the cellar rang with laughter from D&D video games. Gary invited everyone who confirmed an curiosity, together with neighborhood youngsters, obsessive followers who mailed him each week, and players that he met at conventions throughout the Midwest.Gail and Gary Gygax.Picture: Courtesy of Gail GygaxGail wasn’t a lot of a participant, she mentioned, preferring to “be the individual behind the scenes and assist him in no matter he wants,” she mentioned. She not often went down into the Battle Video games room. “I simply didn’t assume his followers would need ‘the girlfriend’ in there,” she mentioned. “It was simply good bonding time for him, his sons and his followers. I’d be within the kitchen cooking meals for them.” She had the business-partnership marriage she’d been in search of, and took her bookkeeping duties severely. In the meantime, she was doing the paperwork to finalize Gary’s divorce from his first spouse. “I’ve at all times felt that one in all Gail’s main pursuits was in caring for Gary,” mentioned Frank Mentzer, the previous TSR recreation designer. “Many occasions over, I noticed Gail performing, working, considering when it comes to defending Gary.” However Gail’s motivation was not easy love, he mentioned. “A part of this was due, in fact, to the well-known historical past of the sport, the corporate, the place folks turned on Gary from the within. Individuals who had been buddies would flip round with their palms out.” Gary was a trusting man who surrounded himself with an entourage of players who, he believed, shared his uncontainable love for the artwork of fantasy. Gary would open the cellar door to anybody who wished to come back in. Gail was the one who put herself between Gary and the enterprise of fantasy when, she believed, that love turned a method to an finish for Gary’s associates.Dungeons & Dragons’ early years in the marketplace weren’t with out their very own controversy. After he left the corporate in 1976, Dave Arneson’s identify was faraway from TSR’s 1977 Monster Guide and 1978 Participant’s Handbook. These had been a part of Superior Dungeons & Dragons, the sport’s second iteration. In 1979, Arneson sued Gygax and TSR for royalties. And by 1985, he would sue once more. At the moment, TSR was about $1.5 million in debt, in response to the e-book Empire of the Creativeness. That yr, a TSR government named Lorraine Williams purchased out the shares held by Gygax’s companions and have become the bulk shareholder in a hostile takeover. Gary Gygax was compelled to resign.Years of authorized troubles adopted. Gary had misplaced the rights to D&D, his very well-known brainchild, and the empire of fantasy it fueled. Quickly, Williams could be threatening a number of authorized actions to ensure Gary’s new fantasy novels, journey modules or role-playing video games relied on no materials he’d generated whereas he was at TSR.Gail busied herself serving to Gary shield his property, just like the Harmful Journeys role-playing recreation that TSR didn’t need to hit the market. Gail spent numerous hours organizing Gary’s property and concepts into folders for these circumstances’ discovery processes. Gary had by no means realized to drive, so Gail allowed him to remain dwelling and write whereas she went and acquired an actual property license. For 5 years in a row, Gary was audited by the state of Wisconsin, she mentioned, and she or he needed to pull the numbers collectively for 3 of these years. Trying on the numbers, Gail wasn’t even certain she wished to legally bind herself to Gary, even after having a toddler with him.Within the late ‘80s, Gail created an organization referred to as Trigee that might maintain the license for all of Gary’s future creations, at the least quickly, and, ultimately, be chargeable for Gary’s substantial authorized debt. Gail mentioned she couldn’t belief anybody else to caretake his writing in any case that had occurred. On prime of her actual property enterprise, she began shopping for and promoting antiques to make ends meet. The couple was borrowing towards Gary’s life insurance coverage. In 1987, Gail and Gary married. Three years later, Gary wrote a will that named Gail as the first beneficiary to all of his bodily and mental property.“Once I married him, he was broke,” Gail mentioned. “Lots of people assume I married him when he had some huge cash. Not solely was he broke, he was in debt, hundreds of thousands of {dollars}. I knew that as a result of I’ve a level in accounting. I might do the maths.” Through the years, the previous archeologist Paul Stormberg had constructed up a friendship with Gary and the remainder of the demigods of the role-playing world on-line, after which ultimately at conventions and wargaming events. As this primary crew of RPG gamers and makers started to cross away, Stormberg’s profession progressively transitioned, he mentioned, from digging up artifacts to serving to promote estates and auctioning notable role-playing ephemera. When a role-playing titan dies, or desires to make some additional money, he preserves, archives, and auctions off their assortment by way of his firm, The Collector’s Trove. TSR artist David Sutherland’s sketches of the Tekumel fantasy warriors went for $3,152; a field of miscellaneous journey manuscripts, correspondence, and design supplies from obscure RPG designer Stephen Marsh went for $8,000.One night, Stormberg mentioned, he and Gary had been chatting on wicker chairs at one in all Gail’s porch events when the subject turned to what would occur after Gary’s demise. On that evening, Stormberg mentioned, Gary requested him to leverage his assortment to assist Gail and Alex. “Folks have truly instructed her, ‘That’s not what Gary would have wished,’” mentioned Stormberg. “Pardon my French, however how the flock did they know what Gary wished? Guess who was there when he died? Gail was. It wasn’t his followers. It was Gail.”Paul Stormberg displaying authentic “character sheets” from the Dungeons & Dragons prototype.Picture: Cecilia D’Anastasio (Kotaku)Since then, Gail and an unique band of accomplices, together with Stormberg, have acted as custodians of Gary Gygax’s property. When Gary handed, Gail was left together with his assortment of some 15,000 objects—board video games, novels, brief tales, video games, and all of the miscellania anticipated of a prolific creator. At the moment, they fill a 12-by-12 storage unit, floor-to-ceiling. Saved elsewhere, someplace much more safe, is Gary’s authentic Citadel Greyhawk, the primary dungeon he ever designed.That is Gail’s world, the ruins of 50 years of Gary’s inventive endeavors, which she navigates alongside a reducing variety of allies whom she trusts. She guards this world fiercely. In her thoughts, there are folks ready eagerly outdoors, plotting to capitalize on the bodily archives of Gary Gygax’s legacy.After the visitor e-book went lacking at Gary’s funeral, Gail estimates she’s misplaced much more issues. A number of copies of Citadel Zagyg: The Higher Works, the identify Gary gave his first dungeon after TSR acquired the rights to the identify “Citadel Greyhawk.” Manuscripts. Gary’s tobacco pipe. All eight copies of the Tomb of Horrors, a uncommon 1978 journey module that prices $60 on the open market. A portray referred to as “Gateway to Journey” she believes is price $50,000.In February 2012, Gail referred to as the police, telling them that her late husband was the developer of Dungeons & Dragons, and that she believed her son Alex’s good friend had stolen manuscripts from the home. In the identical name, Gail mentioned she had manuscripts of Citadel Greyhawk, D&D modules, a e-book of D&D spells, and different objects in a secure deposit field, and that each time she checked the secure deposit field, the stack of papers turned thinner. (In a newer dialog, Gail mentioned the manuscripts had been stolen totally from her dwelling after she took them out of the deposit field.)In response, the police additionally introduced Gail’s son Alex into the police station. He denied his good friend had taken, or would take, something. The police interrogated the good friend, who, in response to the incident report, “didn’t know what a manuscript was.”“Alexander said that since his father handed away, his mom has had a tough time,” the report mentioned. “Alexander said that his mom is careworn … Alexander said that the home is stuffed with muddle. Officer Keller requested Alexander if the manuscripts might probably have been misplaced contained in the residence. Alexander said that it’s doable, however that when he had requested his mom to undergo the home and search for them, she said she didn’t need to as a result of it was too late and the objects had been gone.” Gail urged the police to proceed in search of the manuscripts. One week later, an officer paid a go to to Lake Geneva Video games, the native interest store that runs D&D campaigns. The police wished to see if the manuscripts had handed by way of there. They’d not, an worker mentioned. A number of weeks after that, in response to the police report, Gail mentioned she nonetheless had not checked the secure deposit field to see whether or not the manuscripts had been lacking. “The police reviews are negligent in describing all the pieces that occurred,” Gail instructed me final yr. “They cope with drunks on this city. They don’t cope with theft.”Since Gary’s demise in 2008, Gail has revamped 40 calls to the Lake Geneva police division pertaining to things like alleged break-ins, slashed tires, and threats revamped the web. As soon as, when Gail was within the hospital recovering from kidney failure, her sister Dianne stayed at her dwelling and swore she noticed any person parking in entrance of the home a number of nights in a row smoking a cigarette. “I turned very paranoid myself,” mentioned Dianne. “I acquired the identical feeling she should really feel at occasions.”Gail acts as steward over an unlimited panorama of Gary’s creations, and after he handed, Gail realized how many individuals had been trying to put declare to its numerous territories. Gary was identified to be magnanimous, consistently pausing his work to reply to followers in emails, letters, discussion board posts, even telephone calls. His border coverage was open. A born collaborator, Gary gave nice parts of his thoughts to others for the protecting, and fortunately expanded on the infrastructure of their concepts.As Gary’s spirit was absorbed into the ether—or, extra particularly, was branded right into a goliathan industrial product by Wizards of the Coast, which absorbed TSR in 1997—Gail remains to be mired to the bottom, the place Gary’s unfinished affairs and battles simmer on. There are conflicting views on the truth of these battles, however within the actuality of Gail’s emotional panorama, they’re actual and ever-present. “Gail was his silent companion,” mentioned Stormberg. “However when it got here to enterprise, Gail was his foremost companion. She talked enterprise, he talked inventive, he engaged with followers. So now he’s gone—that charismatic, magnetic man shouldn’t be there. However what do the followers bear in mind? They solely bear in mind how accessible, how loving, how attentive Gary was to them.” Quickly after Gary handed, Gail was approached by Gary’s followers, collaborators, former enterprise companions and hangers-on about what to do together with his legacy. Based on her sister Dianne Curtis, somebody even handed Gail a enterprise card at Gary’s funeral. “The vultures had been surfacing,” she mentioned. Followers wished to do biopics, however few of their concepts had been to her liking. There have been requires numerous creations to be revealed, however Gail wished to completely analysis one of the best ways to develop them. Gail mentioned that two days after Gary’s funeral, Gary’s former agent in Los Angeles flew out to Lake Geneva and requested Gail in individual to let him symbolize Gary’s bio materials. Gail mentioned she’d by no means favored him and didn’t belief him. “He stored writing me threatening letters saying he mentioned he must be the agent promoting Gary’s biopic as a result of he’d identified Gary for thus lengthy.” She mentioned an legal professional ended up charging her $14,000 to clear the matter up.At the moment, a revised version of Citadel Greyhawk was getting launched little by little underneath the Citadel Zagyg identify, together with different properties just like the Gygaxian Fantasy Worlds, Lejendary Adventures and Gord the Rogue. Gail determined to close down the discharge schedule, regardless of the rave evaluations from followers. Livid message board posts adopted. One accused Gail of “holding these rights so tightly that they will’t breathe.” In one other, titled “I’ve an odd feeling about Gail Gygax,” the poster described how he’d learn a number of interviews with Gary—and even completed one himself in his “proudest accomplishment in my recreation journalism profession”—but had by no means “observed any point out or easy trace (moreover Gail being a confidant, in fact) of any function of hers in anyway in Gary’s many creations and enterprises.”I requested Gail why she’d halted publishing. “It must be completed the best means,” she mentioned, “and I wasn’t prepared for it to come back out. It’s part of me now as a result of it was part of Gary.” “A whole lot of occasions, whenever you don’t personal the property, you don’t perceive why any person’s doing one thing,” she mentioned. “Particularly when it’s your funds.” Quickly after the publishing controversy, Gail made strikes to erect a memorial for Gary in Lake Geneva, Wisconsin, the place the place he’d grown up, established TSR, and co-created Dungeons & Dragons. However she wasn’t the primary individual to strategy Lake Geneva’s metropolis parks council and suggest a memorial statue to Gary. It was his daughter, Elise. Someday in the summertime of 2009, Elise shared Gary’s lengthy, storied historical past right into a microphone, a little bit nervous tremor in her voice, earlier than introducing the Gygax Household Memorial, a nonprofit she’d established alongside together with her brother Luke. “What we’d wish to current to the committee is a monument to be positioned in Library Park for the inventive contributions my father gave to the world, a spot for his admirers to pay tribute to him,” she mentioned. Gail appeared a bit offended by the proposal, as she says she had mentioned the challenge with Gary whereas he was residing. She believed it was her proper as Gary’s widow to spearhead any such initiative, and Elise apparently backed off. Gail’s challenge, with the same identify of the Gygax Memorial Fund, acquired lots of press. To lift funds, she offered a few of Gary’s creations at public sale. She made T-shirts. She offered the rights to place inscriptions on the paving bricks that might encompass the statue.Artist Larry Elmore’s proposed design for the Gygax Memorial Statue.Picture: Larry Elmore ( statue itself was envisioned as a dramatic, medieval-style design involving stairs main as much as a fortress embellished with crossed swords and polearms. Gary’s head, rendered in bronze, would sit on the prime whereas, in entrance, a dragon lay in wait. Below the entire thing could be a mechanism for players to depart cube. An artwork critic may discuss with it as “busy.” It was designed by the artist who created one other pop-culture tribute, the “Bronze Fonz” statue in Milwaukee.Gail’s memorial challenge remained a thriller because the years stretched on with none outcomes. “It’s unusual how Gail and her authorized workforce could be so concerned in defending the Gygax identify when it’s utilized by household however there was little if any current motion on the facet of the Gygax Memorial Fund,” learn one discussion board publish. Others dissected the fund’s tax returns line by line, operating analyses on how a lot time Gail and her co-organizers bodily spent on the memorial. A authorities tax submitting for the memorial fund, which is a nonprofit, claims there was $212,000 in it on the finish of 2017. But eight years after fundraising started, there isn’t a memorial to talk of, and the memorial’s web site is offline.It was Paul Stormberg, who had introduced me to the home the place Dungeons & Dragons was created, who took me to the place the Gygax memorial was supposed to face. He walked me over to a big patch of grass behind the lodge I used to be staying in, intersected by an icy river. We had been standing on a cement pathway about fifty yards away from the road. It was a utilitarian, muddy facet yard. “That is the spot,” he mentioned. “What are you able to inform me about this place?” I assumed for a second, wanting round. “There’s been no foot site visitors,” I mentioned. “Precisely,” he responded. “Additionally, this can be a wetland. It floods.”This isn’t what Gail had envisioned for her grand memorial statue. In 2010, Gail had approached Lake Geneva’s board of park commissioners {that a} bust of Gary be positioned in Library Park, the place the place, as a highschool scholar, he would minimize class to learn books and smoke cigarettes. It might be proper on the shoreline and in plain sight. The park council responded that they weren’t certain they wished to impede Chicago vacationers’ view of the lake, Gail says, even if a statue to Chicago Tribune caricature hero Andy Gump has sat on the sting of the lake since 1943. Gail and the fee quickly settled on inserting it within the patch of grass that Paul confirmed me. What the park fee hadn’t thought of, nonetheless, is {that a} statue located in a wetland may sink, and could be costly to keep up. Gail mentioned she is ready for extra favorable circumstances, and stays fixated on the place the place she believes Gary wished his statue. As soon as, when she was on the hospital battling kidney failure, she mentioned she noticed Gary’s spirit come to her, to inform her to not die as a result of she hadn’t completed his statue.Paul Stormberg on the proposed website for Gary Gygax’s memorial.Picture: Creator“I don’t need him wanting in the back of an unpleasant constructing,” Gail mentioned. “I feel a visionary must be dealing with the lake. And Gary was a visionary.” Gail in contrast the statue’s lengthy gestation course of to that of the memorial for Martin Luther King, Jr., which took 20 years. The Lake Geneva Board of Park Commissioners didn’t reply to a number of requests for remark.The transfer contributed to the bubbling-over tensions between Gail and Gary’s kids. As time handed, a gravestone appeared on Gary’s burial website that learn “Beloved father and grandfather.” That stung Gail, she mentioned. Gary’s youngsters had additionally begun to memorialize their father’s life in different methods. After one of many attendees at Gary’s wake in 2008 steered that they make the gathering of his family and friends an annual affair, Luke and Elise based Gary Con, a celebration of his father’s life and work, the following yr. Since then, Gary’s kids, former collaborators, and over 2,000 followers whereas away a weekend yearly on the Grand Geneva Resort, enjoying video games, attending panels, shopping for artwork, and carrying Hawaiian shirts, Gary’s conventional conference apparel.Gail used to attend the present, however stopped in 2016. She mentioned {that a} man named Erik Tenkar, who runs a weblog about old-school role-playing video games, had in non-public conversations joked that Gail would attempt to trademark the phrase “cunt,” and that he would burn the rubber bricks she’d use for her memorial. In his public blogs, he had meticulously documented, and infrequently criticized, Gail’s each public transfer on behalf of Gary’s legacy. Gail mentioned she deliberate on attending the VIP dinner at Gary Con till Luke instructed her that she wouldn’t be snug there since Tenkar could be in attendance. Later, on his weblog, Tenkar wrote in an open letter to Gail that “the attendies [sic] of Gary Con are fairly destructive about your presence.” I reached out to Tenkar to ask about his views. He declined to be interviewed for this story, then posted our total e-mail trade on his weblog. When Kotaku despatched one other e-mail to Tenkar for fact-checking, he didn’t reply, however posted that e-mail on his weblog, too. Tenkar continues to attend Gary Con, and Gail mentioned she remains to be afraid to be round him.Whereas Gail initially had an excellent relationship with Frank Mentzer, the previous D&D designer, that, too, has deteriorated. She says that Mentzer tried to publish one in all her unpublished manuscripts, and when she instructed him to not, he countered by saying that she owed him for a dear storage invoice. Mentzer agrees that his relationship with Gail is acrimonious, however denied this. He says he used to gather TSR’s trash, together with previous manuscripts, none of which had been Gary’s, and solely billed her for photocopying charges incurred when sending her the paperwork she requested. Mentzer is a controversial determine in Gygaxland, too; final month his Gary Con “visitor of honor” standing was eliminated by Luke Gygax, who mentioned in a press release that Mentzer had a historical past of “harassing conduct” and “threatening communications.”Round 2012, Gail additionally discovered herself battling a person named Jayson Elliot, who, together with Luke and Ernie Gygax, was within the technique of launching a role-playing recreation fan journal referred to as Gygax. It might embrace the unique editor of the official Dungeons & Dragons journal, Tim Kask, together with contributions from well-regarded D&D illustrators. Gail filed an utility with america Patent and Trademark Workplace for the Gygax identify on March 4, 2013, one month after Gygax journal’s first subject, precisely 5 years after Gary handed. Elliot filed towards her. That triggered a lawsuit. Gygax journal, points one by way of three.Picture: TSR Video games“Why would you give somebody outdoors the household management over the Gygax identify?” Gail mentioned. For 2 and a half years, Gail mentioned, she “protected the Gygax identify” in a Washington, D.C. court docket. Elliot was ultimately compelled to close down store. He and Gail settled. Luke and Ernie withdrew from the corporate. Elliot’s retelling of the state of affairs is a little bit completely different. “I talked with Gail early on and instructed her we had been doing this and tried to see if she’d be keen on being part of it,” he mentioned over the telephone final month. “We by no means actually acquired wherever with it.” The journal was meant to “pay homage to an amazing man we grew up with,” he mentioned. “The truth that we had been making {a magazine} referred to as Gygax journal didn’t imply we had been ever making an attempt to regulate Gary Gygax’s identify in any means in anyway.” “Her primary aim was to guard Gary, and as a secondary aim, to assist him succeed if she might,” mentioned Frank Mentzer of Gail. “I don’t assume Gail ever had lots of expertise at driving Gary. It was at all times following and defending Gary. With no Gary to drive, when he handed that March, first the shock, after which the conclusion she didn’t know what to do, and she or he needed to make the calls. She’s confronted with a state of affairs that so many individuals had burned Gary, individuals who she thought had been buddies, she didn’t know who to belief.”By 2017, Gail’s calls to the police had slowed to a trickle. She requested for the police to come back by as soon as that yr when she heard banging within the alleyway the place her air conditioner was. Within the morning, she mentioned her air conditioner had fallen down and was mendacity on a rock, probably indicating one thing had been tampered with. Later that yr, she heard her automotive alarm go off in the course of the evening and referred to as the police a few doable breaking and coming into state of affairs. “Unable to find anybody or something suspicious,” the police report learn.For 11 years, Gail looked for the best properties for Gary’s recollections to relaxation and thrive within the daylight of his still-fierce fandom. The best dwelling could be large, money-making, and stewarded by a real fan and acolyte. That is what led her into talks with Hollywood producer Tom DeSanto, whose movies, together with X-Males and Transformers, have grossed over $5 billion. DeSanto owns a group of 40,000 comics and repeatedly attends Comedian-Con San Diego, the place he blends proper in. He has described himself in an interview about Comedian-Con as “purely a fanboy,” a relatable nerd who stumbled into action-movie fame. Seconds after calling himself as a “fanboy,” he name-drops his good friend, Guillermo del Toro.DeSanto has a historical past of selecting by way of dusty attic containers of childhood toys, in search of properties to revive. When one thing strikes him, he may make motions to develop it. DeSanto, who has performed D&D since he was 11, had been speaking to Gail Gygax for eight years, a relationship that he described by way of his lawyer as a “friendship.” In 2016, they made a deal, which is at present the topic of a $30 million lawsuit. Based on a civil grievance filed in Los Angeles Superior Courtroom by Tom DeSanto towards Gail Gygax, the pair “fashioned a partnership” wherein Gail had DeSanto “take accountability” to develop “the mental property rights that she claimed to have inherited from her late husband, Gary Gygax. . . together with the best to make use of his identify and likeness.” The grievance says Gail instructed DeSanto, whom it describes as “one of the crucial profitable producers in Hollywood,” that she was retiring. DeSanto claims that Gail gave him “the unique proper to develop and exploit the Gygax IP in all media, together with movie, TV, video video games, merchandising and licensing, both by himself or by way of third events.” Selection lined the signing of the deal, reporting that DeSanto would change into the “guardian of the library.” The article quotes Gail saying, “Gary at all times envisioned his works changing into actuality in movie/tv and past … Tom’s monitor file speaks for itself, however I used to be impressed with Tom’s enthusiasm for Gary and as a longtime RPG gamer. Tom DeSanto is the right storyteller to carry Gary’s works to life. He’s a real fan.”Tom DeSanto at a Hollywood, California occasion in January, 2019.Picture: Gabriel Olsen (Getty Photographs)Two years after Gygax and DeSanto struck a deal, DeSanto was suing for breach of contract. DeSanto says he spent “hundreds of hours” and “substantial sums of cash” making an attempt to develop the Gygax IP. Talking by way of his lawyer, DeSanto didn’t elaborate on what precisely he was engaged on outdoors of sorting by way of what Gail does and doesn’t personal of Gary’s property, though the grievance mentions a biopic. Over e-mail, DeSanto’s lawyer despatched the next assertion to Kotaku.“My consumer was left no selection however to file a lawsuit looking for to implement the rights promised him within the Gygax IP. Tom has developed and produced a number of the largest franchises in film historical past, and he’s clearly in the very best place of anybody to develop and exploit the very wealthy library of fabric left behind by Gary Gygax. That may be very purpose why Ms. Gygax entrusted it to Tom. We’re greater than sure in our authorized place and, ultimately, everybody stands to profit from enforcement of the settlement, together with and particularly Gail Gygax and her household.”What triggered the lawsuit seems comparatively benign at first, simply one other balloon within the parade of lawsuits that Gary’s legacy has drawn. It was a deal that Gail had made, alongside together with her son Alex and archivist Paul Stormberg, to provide a online game primarily based on Gary’s Citadel Greyhawk, later named Zagyg, with an organization referred to as Fig, which runs a crowdfunding platform for indie video games. DeSanto, who was not concerned, mentioned this was a part of an effort to “freeze” him out. In a response to DeSanto’s lawsuit, Gail contested that she and DeSanto had ever entered right into a partnership and, on prime of that, contests that their contract gave DeSanto rights to Gary’s “total library.” Additional, she says, DeSanto made up her total Selection quote. It’s unclear whether or not Gail meant to offer DeSanto the complete rights to regulate what occurs to her late husband’s creations and identify. Ought to DeSanto prevail in court docket, it will add to the heaviness of the legend story Gail carries on her shoulders—yet another stone of animosity and betrayal to weigh her down, yet another piece of proof that “they” are out for Citadel Greyhawk, the Gygax identify, and the good Gary Gygax mythos. That is the tidy story, the one which is smart within the the linear storyline of victimhood. DeSanto’s lawsuit might have even bigger implications for Gail, ones that don’t slot in that linear storyline. Beneath its allegations of breach of contract and fiduciary responsibility, DeSanto’s go well with claims that Gail doesn’t, in reality, personal the rights to Gary’s legacy as freely and clearly as she claims.In Might 2017, DeSanto’s go well with reads, he realized that Gary Gygax had a second will. He wrote it shortly earlier than his demise. That may, in response to the grievance, merely provides Gail a life property to a few of Gary’s IP—the components his kids couldn’t declare. That will imply that, when Gail dies, DeSanto would not have the rights to develop Gygax properties, making their contract nugatory.Gail agrees that it will exists, however denies that it’s legitimate. She says it was not signed appropriately, including no person had ever contacted her concerning the will’s validity earlier than DeSanto. Gail mentioned she is now writing her personal biography of Gary, one which takes place in Citadel Greyhawk deep by way of the dungeon’s alternate actuality. Like the situation of her proposed memorial statue, this, too, is a challenge that she mentioned the spirit of Gary steered to her in a dream, telling her to put in writing a particular perception into his household historical past, issues he’d mentioned simply to her. It’s a kids’s story, one which begins: “A mom studying to her son / A father telling bedtime tales / And the present of a e-book from a stranger.”In December, Lake Geneva’s shoreline is bordered by an enormous, spindly ice fortress, created by native artists. A large frozen maze of spires and icicles, it winds round and across the icy seashore. Crawlspace tunnels, fountains, and slides entertain kids as they discover these snow-covered towers stretching to the sky.Close to the fortress is a water fountain, drained and lined over for the winter, surrounded by engraved paving stones. Right here, there may be the city’s solely public memorial to Gary Gygax, positioned by Gary’s kids, years after Elise approached the Lake Geneva Park Fee about her personal concept for a memorial statue. Surrounded by different inscribed bricks is one which reads “In Loving Reminiscence of E. Gary Gygax, Creator of Dungeons & Dragons, Donated by His Household, Associates and Followers.” Amidst these phrases is an illustration of a 20-sided die, and atop it, a sleeping dragon, curled round it as if guarding a treasure.