Skip to content

The Teen Idol Vanishes

Soraya Roberts | Longreads | March 2019 | eight minutes (2,230 phrases)
Dylan McKay was by no means fairly there. Within the bodily sense — he would type of simply flip up out of nowhere on Beverly Hills, 90210, in random staircases or beneath random vehicles, and disappear simply as quick — but in addition, like, existentially. He was purported to be a excessive schooler, however you might by no means think about him at school, losing interest, studying. He appeared to know every little thing there was to know anyway, although he was solely 17 — however he wasn’t actually 17. He had this type of aged face, with the eyebrow scar, the endless stacks of strains on his brow, the throwback pompadour, the Homeric sideburns, and appeared to have the sexual historical past of a middle-aged playboy. Relying on the circumstances, he exuded the hard-partying previous of a retired rock star or the bodhisattva-like knowledge of an historic yogi. Though he had supposedly hit puberty solely 4 years in the past.
All of this resulted in an otherworldly, ageless icon of adolescence that was unattainable to know utterly due to the way in which it continuously vacillated between poles — young and old, violent and mild, good and goofy, wealthy and poor, private and non-private. However Dylan McKay’s was the type of mythic narrative that would solely float alongside on a dearth of particulars, the holes stuffed in by our imaginations. By a pubescent lady, for example, who thought the “Dylan” in her new class can be one thing just like the Dylan at West Beverly solely to seek out he was as acne-ridden and awkward as she was as a result of he was an precise teenager. Versus Luke Perry, a 24-year-old actor whose biography was so elusive that Dylan McKay stood in for him, turning each of them into this perennial summary image of romantic teenage-hood.
So when Luke Perry died out of the blue earlier this week following a stroke on the age of 52, it was a specific shock as a result of…he was 17, proper? The demise of Luke Perry was the demise of Dylan McKay, although the Dylan McKay all of us remembered dates again to 1993. That was the time when a teen heartthrob may nonetheless outline a era; possibly not as singularly as within the ’50s, however way more so than at present. As a result of when Dylan McKay arrived in 1990 on the primary teen cleaning soap, so-called youth tradition had already been established and ladies have been acquainted with icons of masturbation (sorry, masculinity). There have been teen magazines, there have been teen reveals and music and films. With out 24/7 media, with out the web, a fiction like Dylan McKay may overtake a reality like Luke Perry. However after him, the deluge: there have been much more teen reveals and music and films and extra media, fracturing the idolatry business into a number of components. Now there are too many alternate options — too many automobiles, too many teenagers in them, too many teenagers consuming them — to have one particular person signify all issues; if everyone seems to be an icon, nobody is an icon. However Dylan McKay’s — I imply, Luke Perry’s — demise reminds us, at the least for a second,  that the teenager idol was as soon as very a lot alive.
From Franz Liszt within the 1840s to Rudy Vallée within the 1920s to Frank Sinatra within the 1940s, little ladies have been all the time swooning over boys. Is it as a result of so many actual boys have been horrible, that these fantasy boys with out all of the constraints of the quotidian may develop into the right avatars for the love these ladies deserved? “The teenager idol by no means seems to be autonomous and due to this fact by no means seems to be threatening as an grownup,” writes P. David Marshall in Movie star and Energy: Fame in Modern Tradition. “He stays, so long as he’s fashionable, perpetually childlike and dependent.” He. At all times he. However “he” additionally meant intercourse. These idolized guys have been an outlet for adolescent feminine want that was in any other case ignored — this was the sexual gratification offered by Elvis Presley’s gyrating hips, Marlon Brando’s renegade leather-based smolder, and, after all, James Dean’s angsty white-tee’d insurgent. The latter was a very potent image, having died at solely 24, earlier than the discharge of Insurgent And not using a Trigger; demise trapped him in an afterlife plastered on the partitions of teenage ladies. Like Perry, he appeared world-weary, older than he was. The 2 actors have been the identical age when their stars flared — one burning out, the opposite lighting up — and their spirits appeared by some means related.
“There’s all the time somebody being known as the subsequent James Dean,” Perry informed The Chicago Tribune newspaper in 1991. “However there was just one. And he’s lifeless.” As if to underscore his level, Eve Babitz revealed a characteristic the subsequent yr in Esquire, titled “They May Be Giants,” which featured Perry alongside three different younger actors — his co-stars Jason Priestley and Jamie Walters, and a few man I’ve actually by no means heard of named Dana Ashbrook (oh wait, I appeared him up, he was in Twin Peaks) — who appeared like James Dean, all of them styled identically in denims, white shirts, and black boots. “It’s harmful to name anybody the brand new James Dean,” Babitz wrote, “as a result of even the outdated one discovered being himself considerably unattainable.” Within the unfold, Perry is the one one not smiling.
Dylan McKay actually wasn’t there at the beginning — he didn’t arrive till the second episode of 90210. Out of the darkish of a highschool robotics lab, he emerges to defend a geek towards a few jocks about to delete all of his onerous work. You hear his voice first, that soporific, almost-bored soft-drawl: “Contact that board, my good friend,” he says, as we see him from behind, subsequent to an electrical energy ball making electrical energy sounds, as if Dylan McKay is being conjured like Frankenstein. Then he turns round and we’re face-to-face along with his furrowed forehead and that top brow and better hair: “Please. Contact it. the tragedy of this nation is that cretins such as you two find yourself working it.” (Oh, man, Dylan was prophetic too!) Then, like greased lightning, he vanishes, and 90210’s star Brandon Walsh says, “Your good friend’s fairly cool.” Then the least cool guitar that ever guitared amps up and Dylan and Brandon are browsing (don’t ask me) and when Brandon asks one of many surfers if she is aware of Dylan, she says, “Who does?”
“After the pilot, we felt there needs to be somebody who’s just a little harmful, just a little on the sting, and we got here up with the Dylan character,” 90210 government producer Aaron Spelling informed Rolling Stone in 1992, with creator Darren Star including, “When Luke walked into the audition, it was like ‘Wow, that’s the particular person.’” Perry was a kind of small-town children who got here to Hollywood to make it large and type of… didn’t. After leaving Ohio upon graduating highschool, he starred in two soaps — One other World and Loving — then hung out laying asphalt to pay the payments. In 1992, he informed Vainness Honest that he solely felt at residence, “anywhere that I’m alone.” I didn’t know any of this as a child, after all, as a result of as a child you don’t examine your crushes in newspapers or Individuals journal and also you aren’t up late sufficient to observe Leno. You get what you see on the quilt of teenage magazines — a cute image, however not a lot else — and on TV, and that defines every little thing. And once you flip up at a mall to see this man (I didn’t, he by no means confirmed up at mine) who seems to be type of like a grownup, you aren’t actually turning up for Luke Perry, however Dylan McKay. He’s the one price fainting over. “I’m a easy man,” Perry informed Individuals in 1991. “I don’t want an entire lot.” Neither did we.
We received posters (Luke Perry was the highest vendor in 90210), we received dolls, the fortunate ones received mall appearances or auctioned dates. However largely we received this man of indeterminate age and provenance, who we have been informed was cool, who handled an inexperienced lady with smoldering child gloves. Although Dylan and Brenda Walsh (Brandon’s twin) didn’t develop into a factor till episode 10, three months into the present’s first season, that’s when anybody began actually caring. That gave him a re-do. This time when he first meets a Walsh twin, he’s all soiled beneath a motor. One of many first issues he says to Brenda, after rolling up with a sexual innuendo is, “I noticed you.” He asks her out whereas rising from the bathe, dripping. He’s rather a lot: On their first date he fights along with his dad, nearly takes a drink, breaks a flower pot, after which makes out with Brenda. He actually wears his equivocation on his sleeve when he dons a cashmere sweater to fulfill Daddy Walsh earlier than overlaying it with a leather-based jacket for Daughter Brenda. At episode 21, the Spring Dance the place he and Brenda have intercourse for the primary time, he formally grew to become the present’s go-to heartthrob. “We’ll make our look,” he tells Brenda, holding up a set of lodge keys, “after which we’ll make our disappearance.”
The indefinable paradox of Dylan McKay, who results in a predictable love triangle with brunette Brenda and her blonde finest good friend Kelly, points from the primary three seasons of 90210, which concluded within the spring of 1993 (although the present lasted for one more seven). However Luke Perry already had one foot out the door in 1992, when he performed Dylan’s reverse in Buffy the Vampire Slayer (the film). Pike was a “loser” whose brow (and wrinkles) was obscured by bangs, who wore a trench coat as a substitute of a leather-based jacket, and who shaved off his sideburns as a substitute of rising them out for promenade.  After all, he nonetheless rode a motorcycle and had a soul patch rather than a soul, as a result of Luke Perry had a humorousness. However with out Dylan McKay, the actor all however vanished. A wedding to a civilian in 1993, Individuals introduced, “ended Perry’s reign as one among Hollywood’s most eligible bachelors.” In the identical story, an editor for each the ridiculously named Bop and Large Bopper stated the hysteria round him was “over.” A month later, Leisure Weekly cited him in its eulogy, “The demise of teenage pinups,” as if his step again from 90210 and Dylan McKay had pushed within the stake. Nevertheless it was true; teen journal circulation was down, a saturation of teenage reveals meant no particular person stars, and, anyway, company leisure not needed to focus on teenagers alone. As we speak, with celebrities as digitally ubiquitous as they’re, an summary iconic model of their personas is not doable. All that to say: there are not any extra lone icons of adolescence in America (although Timothée Chalamet is definitely giving it the outdated school attempt).
Though Luke Perry tried to shed Dylan McKay — he performed a post-apocalyptic loner within the collection Jeremiah (2002-2004), a reverend in Oz (2000-2002) — he accepted his legacy and reverted again to himself in The Simpsons, Johnny Bravo, and Household Man. As he informed Swedish newspaper Aftonbladet in 2008, in a quote that circulated closely this previous week, “I’m going to be linked with him till I die, however that’s really simply positive. I created Dylan McKay. He’s mine.” 9 years later, on the self-aware, homage-fueled Archie comedian adaptation Riverdale, he totally succumbed, enjoying Archie Andrew’s dad, Fred, a meta-moral compass advising a teenage son who finds himself in a well-known blonde-brunette love triangle. Perry appeared amid a forged of social media-savvy stars, none of whom are as iconic as he’s, however none of whom are as nameless as he’s both. Our collective public mourning for Perry unites us in a shared nostalgia for an imaginary previous, staving off our growing sense of alienation. There’ll unlikely be the same group expertise for his Riverdale co-stars, however maybe that’s higher for them as people. When Perry popped up of their Instagram feeds, it was paying homage to that bizarre electrical energy ball from his first episode of 90210, some type of otherworldly cosmic intervention. As a result of we’re not meant to see what’s behind Dylan McKay.
Within the midst of my analysis I discovered an outdated 1991 interview with Luke Perry, his first with Leisure Tonight, when he was round 25. I didn’t see it when it initially aired; I might have been all of 11. From the place I’m sitting now, at 39, following Perry’s demise at 52, he seems to be tiny and so younger, in a gray tank high, speaking to a muffled voice off digital camera, a bit bashful, fidgety, joking a couple of passing airplane. His voice is much less clean, his hair lifts previous the sting of the body, his forehead is as flat as a new child’s. That is Luke Perry, not Dylan McKay, and I don’t know him. At one level he seems to be the youngest I’ve ever seen him on tv, sucking his lips and protruding his jaw to puzzle over a query about whether or not his followers are shouting for his character or for him. “They’re screaming Luke, ‘trigger they know that’s what my identify is however, they don’t actually know Luke too nicely,” he says, smiling and considerably sheepish. “They know Dylan.”  And, simply as he predicted twenty years later, Dylan McKay was the identify we have been all saying when he handed, as a result of that was the identify we knew.
* * *
Soraya Roberts is a tradition columnist at Longreads.
Like this:Like Loading…