Skip to content

Getting older onto the road: Practically half of older homeless individuals fell into hassle after 50

For the previous six years, Joe White has been waking up each morning in a parking zone in downtown Oakland. Some days, it’s freezing. Different days, he’s baking, drenched or, typically, tolerably comfy.

One fixed is the asphalt: It’s all the time laborious. And meals, which White has to guard from the rats that squirm by means of the outlet they’ve chewed by means of his tent door, all the time requires a hunt.
However he’s OK, he says. He’s powerful, and he must be. He’s 68 years previous.
White is at an age when many senior residents are within the easy-chair part of life, taking grandkids out for ice cream and touring for enjoyable. Not White — and never an rising quantity of people that, like him, fell into homelessness previous their 50th birthdays.
In a examine that raises alarms about an more and more tattered security internet for low-income seniors in America, researchers have discovered that simply wanting half — 44 p.c — of all homeless individuals older than 50 years previous hit the streets for the primary time after they had been 50.
Dr. Margot Kushel (proper) hugs affected person Shawn Martin, homeless and about to show 75, at San Francisco Basic Hospital. Kushel led a examine on the getting old homeless inhabitants. (Carlos Avila Gonzalez / The Chronicle | San Francisco Chronicle)Whereas a full half of the nation’s individuals residing with out properties are older than 50, it’s the rising variety of those that fall into homelessness after that age that the majority considerations Margot Kushel, the us professor who heads the examine. The issue is very acute within the Bay Space, the place housing prices, together with rents, have risen dramatically over the previous decade.
The examine’s discovering speaks to the hazard of a shrinking skill of individuals to adequately lower your expenses and make different preparations for retirement, Kushel stated. And it signifies, she stated, that there’s too little assist in place to catch them earlier than they fall into homelessness when laborious instances hit.
Maybe most disturbingly, it displays society’s ambivalence towards the plight of the aged, she stated.

“It ought to shock us as a nation that now we have this drawback,” Kushel stated. “It’s nearly too painful to understand.”
Kushel, whose examine simply concluded its fifth 12 months and has simply been renewed for one more 5, stated White and the 450 different individuals she’s been monitoring function a warning {that a} veritable tidal wave of older individuals will in all probability be residing on the streets within the coming years.
A separate examine on getting old homeless, launched final month by different researchers, echoed Kushel’s considerations and projected that the aged homeless inhabitants will almost triple over the following decade.
Again and again, she stated, the story is similar: An individual works into late center age at a low-wage job, hanging in there however unable to avoid wasting a lot cash, after which hassle strikes. She or he can not swing a hammer, sling a shovel, stand all day in entrance of a money register, drive lengthy shifts in a truck.
The dad and mom in a multigenerational rental residence die, and people left behind can’t afford to remain. Or the older girl or man they had been caring for as a house well being aide dies, and so does the job.
Or they develop into disabled, like White, whose left knee is so badly broken the kneecap juts out at a sickening 45-degree angle from the place it needs to be.
“The issue right here is just not a scarcity of willingness to work, or psychological well being — it’s a society that doesn’t care, doesn’t have an satisfactory security internet constructed, particularly for our senior residents,” Kushel stated. “That is what occurs whenever you pay individuals a minimal wage they’ll’t stay on and is value lower than it was once, there’s approach too little reasonably priced housing, and there are virtually no pensions anymore. They had been by no means capable of construct wealth, save for his or her previous age.

“You place all these collectively, and we’re ‘shocked, shocked shocked’ that homelessness amongst older individuals is rising?”
Knowledge from the Financial Coverage Institute, a Washington, D.C., nonprofit that research labor points, present that in the present day’s federal minimal hourly wage of $7.25 must truly be set at $19 to pay for meals, housing and different prices in the identical approach doable in 1970. In the meantime, the typical worth of a home has quadrupled nationwide since 1980, and the median lease has doubled, in response to on-line actual property databases Zillow and ApartmentList. Within the Bay Space, the place rents are the best within the nation, the challenges are extra extreme. In San Francisco, even town’s $15 minimal wage can’t bridge the livability hole.
A tent sits atop an deserted RV at an encampment alongside Wooden Road in West Oakland, a rising sight within the Bay Space. (Jessica Christian / The Chronicle | San Francisco Chronicle)“On this market, within the Bay Space, 10 or 15 years in the past we’d not have discovered the amount of older homeless people who we see day by day — we’re simply seeing an increasing number of of them on a regular basis,” stated John Weeks, a coordinator of the us examine. “When issues went unsuitable, you possibly can nonetheless lease a room, discover a place someplace, get by someway. Not now.”
Kushel, one of many nation’s foremost researchers into geriatric homelessness, co-wrote the primary examine, in 2006, exhibiting that the typical age of homeless individuals within the U.S. was within the mid-50s.
Her newest examine, titled “Hope-House,” doesn’t attain again to the 1980s, when trendy homelessness started. So she has no solution to estimate how many individuals had been turning into homeless after 50 then. However the regular graying of the road inhabitants since 1990 is critical sufficient to portend a coming disaster for seniors, she stated. In 1990, solely 11 p.c of the inhabitants nationwide was 50 or older, in response to UCSF statistics. In the present day it’s 50 p.c.

Visible Essay: Homeless after 50 on Bay Space streets

“Margot is doing crucial work,” stated Dennis Culhane, a professor on the College of Pennsylvania who led final month’s examine projecting a tripling of aged avenue inhabitants. He agreed with Kushel that her analysis displays a nationwide drawback, not simply the Bay Space’s.

“We must always all be very involved about this,” Culhane stated. “It’s going to be very upsetting to individuals to see so many extra aged people who find themselves homeless, however that’s mainly what we face: a rising getting old and frail homeless inhabitants.”
Kushel, who discovered her examine contributors in Oakland, is monitoring them all through Northern California as they cycle out and in of shelters, camps and stays with buddies or household. A lucky few have gotten into everlasting housing. In exploring how they cope, she and her researchers have discovered that that homeless older of us have much more hassle with despair, eyesight, listening to, stability, and performing common day by day actions corresponding to bathing or dressing than housed individuals their age.
That’s unsurprising, Kushel stated. Homeless individuals of their 50s usually show the geriatric difficulties of individuals age 75 or 80. Meaning caring for the approaching increase in older avenue individuals will probably be costly.
“We’re going to need to get our shelters and our supportive housing prepared for an older inhabitants, with extra intensive medical care — lodging for individuals who have the wants of 80-year-olds,” Kushel stated. “We additionally have to increase our consideration to forestall seniors from turning into homeless to start with, maybe by giving subsidies to allow them to stick with households, the best way we do for youngsters by means of little one welfare providers.”

About 80 p.c of the us examine contributors are African American. Throughout America, a disproportionate 43 p.c of homeless persons are black, a quantity mirrored within the Bay Space. In distinction, simply 13 p.c of the nationwide inhabitants is black.
Kushel attributes this native and nationwide disparity to a grim historical past of redlining, financial oppression and different ills.
“We’re going to need to make some laborious choices as a society to handle how racial inequality impacts so many issues, however on this case, homelessness,” she stated. “For one, now we have to extra vigorously implement truthful housing legal guidelines. Create extra reasonably priced housing for everybody. Pay individuals one thing they’ll truly stay on.
“This can take some painful and sincere conversations about housing segregation and revenue inequality. However they’re conversations now we have to have if we don’t need it to worsen.”
Three Bay Space residents in Kushel’s examine spoke with The Chronicle about how they ended up homeless after age 50. Listed below are their tales:
Wayne Shannon, 74, lives at Altenheim Senior Housing in Oakland, the place he moved after turning into homeless after a layoff. (Jessica Christian / The Chronicle | San Francisco Chronicle)Wayne Shannon
The general public in Kushel’s examine had been low-income earlier than they grew to become indigent. However some weren’t. They had been simply laid low by unhealthy luck, a debilitating harm — or, like Wayne Shannon, by an incapacity or unwillingness to plan for his or her golden years.
Shannon is 74 and labored a full profession as a draftsman, having earned a bachelor’s diploma in 1973 in industrial arts at San Jose State College. He held nice jobs one after the opposite, working on the Lawrence Livermore Nationwide Laboratory and Chevron, along with contractor gigs in Alaska and the Philippines. However he by no means stayed lengthy in anyone place, and he didn’t save his cash.
He additionally by no means married. By no means had youngsters. And a few years in the past offered the one rental he ever purchased.
In 2001, at 56, he discovered himself laid off from what grew to become his final job. Too younger to start receiving Social Safety, he couldn’t afford lease anyplace within the Bay Space. So he started residing in a van. That’s the place he was when Kushel’s group discovered him at a soup kitchen 5 years in the past and recruited him into the examine.
Wayne Shannon lived in his van till shifting into senior housing in Oakland with a governmental housing subsidy. (Images By Jessica Christian / The Chronicle | San Francisco Chronicle)“I assume I didn’t assume issues by means of,” he stated in a habitually sluggish, cautious tone. “I by no means stayed in a job lengthy sufficient to place down roots, and my retirement plan was to gather Social Safety. However who knew issues would get so costly?
“I by no means thought I’d be residing in a van. Time simply type of snuck up on me.”
Shannon stated he has all the time believed in carrying his personal weight, and except for utilizing veteran medical providers — he was an Military sergeant within the Vietnam Warfare — he asks little or no of anybody. He lived in his van till it fell aside two years in the past. With a governmental housing subsidy, he moved into senior housing in Oakland.
That’s the place he’s in the present day, now fastidiously managing his price range from a month-to-month Social Safety verify and making common three-hour journeys to the Fort Miley VA Medical Middle in San Francisco for checkups on diabetes, a crushed vertebrae and different illnesses he picked up from his time with no everlasting roof.
Shannon visits his two brothers within the Central Valley, however solely at vacation time.
“You don’t wish to impose,” Shannon stated. “We’re imagined to handle ourselves in America, and that’s what I do. I’d by no means consider imposing on my family members. They’re good individuals, and I see them at Thanksgiving and the like, however I’ve all the time taken care of myself. And I’m wonderful with that.”
Echoing that sentiment is Shannon’s brother, who additionally had a full profession — in water administration — however deliberate extra successfully earlier than retiring to Lodi (San Joaquin County).
“Wayne has not ever requested us if he might stay with us,” Warren Shannon stated. “It’s not out of animosity or disunity. We do love one another. However he’s unbiased.”
Joe White, 68, homeless for six years, sweeps round his longtime encampment close to 13th and Alice streets in Oakland final month earlier than he moved into transitional housing. (Jessica Christian / The Chronicle | San Francisco Chronicle)Joe White
His ruined knee is what steered Joe White to a soggy tent on the asphalt in downtown Oakland.
He put in a decades-long profession as a meals providers employee for the Oakland Unified College District earlier than he fell off a ladder, severely fractured his kneecap and all the pieces round it, and ended his profession. An operation to restore the knee failed. That was six years in the past, when he was 62. He by no means noticed homelessness coming.
“I labored all my life till I used to be in my 60s, damage my knee and couldn’t work anymore,” he stated not too long ago as he fastidiously unfolded a batch of rain-drenched garments and unfold them out on his parking zone residence. “I by no means in one million years thought I’d wind up right here on this parking zone, residing like this. No sir.”
A tear trickled from one eye as he smoothed out a crease in his denims, which, like his black jacket and sneakers, had been tidy and clear — not the indicators of man who’d been sleeping in a tattered tent within the rain.
“It’s been a tough wrestle, man,” he stated quietly. “However I’m not the one one. I see numerous previous guys like me out right here. It’s getting worse. Not higher.”
White’s parking zone is on 13th Road, throughout from the historic Resort Oakland, the place film stars and presidents from Wilson to Roosevelt stayed earlier than it was changed into a senior residents residence. Over time, he has develop into a considerably beloved determine on his block.
Joe White has been reluctant to maneuver out of his Oakland tent, however is working with counselors to get a everlasting studio with authorities help. (Images By Jessica Christian / The Chronicle | San Francisco Chronicle)He wears an enormous smile and chats up everybody who stops by. He watches after individuals’s vehicles once they’re at work. He studies issues when he sees them.
It’s a typical method for older homeless individuals residing outdoors — they develop into what some avenue counselors name neighborhood “mascots.” Keep good, assist out, don’t be an issue, and also you gained’t get rousted. You’re too previous to actually combat with anybody, so create your personal peace as a lot as doable.
For White, it’s not all the time simple. Generally the throbbing in his broken knee is so unhealthy that he has to warmth a needle in his tent and lance it to empty it out. However he manages.
“What amazes me about Joe is how he’s created his personal group on the market,” stated Corinne Jan, who works close by. “Some individuals outdoors isolate themselves, and it’s more durable to know them, know what to anticipate. Not Joe. Everyone is aware of him and likes him.”
Jan is head of Household Bridges, a nonprofit that helps low-income households discover assets, and this winter she took White on as a mini-project. She related him with a transitional housing program, and although White doesn’t like crowded buildings, preferring to remain in his tent more often than not, he’s working with counselors to get a everlasting studio with authorities help.
“CJ — she’s a really sharp girl, and she or he cares,” he stated throughout a go to to her workplace. “She opened up my coronary heart.”
“You are able to do this, Joe,” Jan stated, leaning her face near his. “I do know you will get inside. You simply need to hold with it.”
When Michelle Myers, 62, was recognized with abdomen most cancers, her room on the Harrison Resort in Oakland grew to become everlasting. She had been residing in her automotive after dropping her residence. (Jessica Christian / The Chronicle | San Francisco Chronicle)Michelle Myers
About 30 p.c of older homeless individuals bunk with household from time to time, Kushel’s group has discovered — however they usually can’t keep. Most of the time, the family members are barely hanging on economically themselves and may’t afford to completely present for one more mouth on the dinner desk, Kushel stated.
“There’s numerous pleasure amongst these older homeless individuals,” she stated. “Lots of lower-income households lease locations with restrictions, and so they don’t wish to screw up the lease by staying there towards the principles.
“And if there’s another particular person in the home, that’s another who’s consuming, flushing the bathroom, utilizing the lights. Time and time once more, they are saying, ‘I don’t wish to take meals out of my grandbaby’s mouth, so I’d quite be outdoors and handle myself. However as a lot as something, they only plain don’t wish to impose.’”
That’s how it’s with 62-year-old Michelle Myers.
A waitress who raised three sons alone, she’d been residing together with her father with solely intermittent jobs till 2013, when he died of most cancers. Her mom had died just a few years earlier. Earlier than that, her second husband died of a coronary heart assault.
And not using a guardian or partner to share lease, she burned by means of her paltry financial savings, couldn’t discover work — and wound up residing in her Volkswagen bug. Heroin quickly captured her. She gave up.
After a well being disaster, Michelle Myers discovered government-funded residential placement at  the Harrison Resort in Oakland. (Images By Jessica Christian / The Chronicle | San Francisco Chronicle)“Within the state I used to be in, I didn’t — and don’t — wish to be a burden to my youngsters,” she stated. “So I simply tried to deal with issues myself. Didn’t work out very effectively.
“It’s laborious to get assist whenever you’re like that, no cash, no residence. Folks push you away since you’re older. They down-rate you. Yeah, it’s my fault I did medicine. Everybody makes errors. However my gosh, how our society neglects its older individuals.”
Touchdown in a hospital with pneumonia two years in the past saved her — together with the kindness proven her by Kushel’s examine group. Inspired by the researchers to just accept the assistance the hospital workers provided her, she enrolled in a residential rehab program and bought clear. A 12 months in the past Myers scored one in all Oakland’s scarce government-funded residential placements for the homeless and moved into the Harrison Resort supportive housing advanced.
Her room was imagined to be non permanent, however final month it grew to become everlasting when she was recognized with abdomen most cancers — which got here on prime of an present HIV analysis.
Just a few years in the past, Myers stated, she might need crumbled with the diagnoses.

“Not now,” she stated, standing within the century-old, restored residential lodge and grinning as she noticed the solar peeping by means of her window. “I’m choosing myself up. I pray. I am going to church. I keep clear. Seniors shouldn’t need to undergo what I’ve gone by means of, however I gained’t be a burden to my sons.
“I bought fortunate right here. Not everybody else is. No sir, no. I’ve had too many buddies wind up in coffins too early.”
Kevin Fagan is a San Francisco Chronicle workers author. E mail: Twitter: @KevinChron older-onto-the-street-Practically-half-of-older-13668900.php