Skip to content

Who’s the Largest Pop Star?

It was once simple to rank music—for many years, Billboard’s rating was primarily based on radio performs or album gross sales. At the moment, music consumption has turn out to be so fragmented that there’s no single solution to measure recognition: we’ve received Spotify, Apple Music, Pandora, Soundcloud, YouTube, radio, album gross sales, and touring.
However every of those platforms skews in direction of a particular viewers—think about a rating primarily based purely on CD gross sales! Billboard constructed a posh equation to take care of this, however a small tweak in sources or weighting would change who the world considers its greatest star. We are able to’t definitively measure recognition, however we fake that we will with Billboard’s rating, which stays our default psychological mannequin of tradition.
The Pudding’s crew debated this existential musical query and had a number of ideas to think about.

Outlined by Live performance Venue Measurement

By Caitlyn Ralph & Amber Thomas

An artist’s dwell exhibits actually give a way of their recognition. It’s a bodily illustration of how many individuals care about an artist to trace the tour, buy a ticket earlier than it sells out, and transport themselves to look at the efficiency.
With that mentioned, it’s utterly lacking from Billboard’s algorithm. When historians look again on 2018, they need to report on those that carried out to the biggest audiences on the biggest excursions.

All Artists Should

have carried out considered one of these iconic venues in 2018: Madison Sq. Backyard in NYC, The Discussion board in LA, or TD Backyard in Boston
have launched new music in 2017 or 2018, and are due to this fact supporting an album cycle

How The Stars Have been Calculated

discover all concert events performed by artist in 2018
measure venue dimension
sum to seek out what number of seats they performed to in 2018

Seats booked in 2018

Outlined by YouTube Views

By Matt Daniels

Billboard’s algorithm is closely weighted in direction of streams by paid accounts, which principally means the rating is no matter’s performed by folks with premium accounts on Spotify and Apple Music. Billboard determined that music tradition is anybody who can afford to pay $10/month.
On a worldwide stage, that is much more egregious—in lots of international locations, $10/month is a luxurious afforded to solely the rich. It’s additionally biased in direction of locations the place Spotify exists, which excludes India (#2 nation on the earth, 17% of the world’s inhabitants). That’s why the #1 artist on YouTube, Ozuna, had extra streams in 2018 (10.7 billion) than Drake, the #1 artist on Spotify (8.2 billion).

*Spotify launched a rating of artists by streams. For some artists, their stream counts had been launched too.
YouTube is a greater proxy of recognition. It has international attain, there’s no barrier to entry to hearken to music, and there’s no barrier to entry to add music (i.e., labels nonetheless management what’s performed on radio).

Outlined by Complete variety of gifs

By Jan Diehm

I’m in my early 30s and I nonetheless stan the queen, Ms. Britney Spears.
A few years in the past I made the cross-country pilgrimage to see her carry out in Vegas. A little bit over an hour into singing each single phrase and dancing my butt off, I needed to sit down as a result of I wasn’t getting sufficient oxygen. My spouse promptly quipped, “Even Britney doesn’t sing that a lot!” (I imply, Brit’s had her justifiable share of “Me In opposition to the Music” moments, however I nonetheless love her).
And that brings us to my argument: pop stars shouldn’t be measured on musical success alone—they’re cultural icons. The most important ones creep into the zeitgeist and turn out to be the issues we share and meme. To measure this, I’m utilizing the whole variety of gifs by artist in GIPHY’s search outcomes.

All Artists Should

have appeared in Billboard’s Prime 100 of 2017 or 2018

How The Stars Have been Calculated

discover all artists who meet the above standards
take away any duplicate artists and collaborations
search GIPHY for every artist and document the whole variety of gifs

Artists, ranked by GIF depend on Giphy

P!nk was faraway from the dataset as a result of a seek for her identify returned too many gifs that had been solely associated to the colour pink. Additionally, shout out to twenty one pilots for showing in two Prime 10s to date.

Outlined by Mentions on Reddit

By Jack Beckwith, Michael Hester, and Sam Vickars of The DataFace

Lately, artists’ promotional efforts are not confined to excursions and occasional press runs. They’re connecting with followers continually by way of social media and constructing private manufacturers that reach past the music. Youthful artists have used this to their benefit, as latest up-and-comers like Lil Pump and Cardi B have grown their clout by way of likes and shares earlier than signing main label offers.
On this world, artists needs to be judged on their means to drive digital conversations. So we’ve turned to Reddit as our knowledge supply, counting the variety of feedback throughout the platform that talked about every artist. Sure, Reddit tends to skew pretty younger and male. But it surely’s additionally one of many largest social networks on the earth with a powerful international attain.

All Artists Should

have appeared in Billboard’s Prime 100 in 2018

How The Stars Have been Calculated

compile a listing of artists who meet the above standards together with any nicknames
depend complete mentions of every artist throughout all Reddit feedback in 2018

Prime Artists on Reddit, Sized by variety of feedback

A number of artists (like Future and Logic) had been faraway from the dataset as a result of their names had been too much like frequent English phrases.

Outlined by Social Followers

By Ilia Blinderman & Russell Goldenberg

Pop is brief for common. And let’s be sincere, pop music has by no means been simply concerning the music—it’s at all times had some facet of “how many individuals are actively being attentive to you?” Fortunately for us, we will quantify that by trying, fairly actually, at their followers through social platforms. Introducing your new King of Pop: Justin Bieber.

Artists, ranked by followers on social channels


So, who wins? Ought to we give the crown to the always-on-tour Dave Matthews Band? Is YoungBoy’s YouTube attain a real reflection of stardom? Or ought to we award high spot to 2 Chainz’s meme-ability, Kanye’s means to garner controversy, or Justin Bieber’s mind-boggling social following?
Arguments could be made for any considered one of these artists, and in some sense, that’s the purpose: utilizing a data-driven method to answering a cultural query appears inherently authoritative, however a number of data-driven strategies of approaching exist. Which of those is greatest stays a query for the researchers and the viewers to reply collectively.

Illustration by Dan Evans